Laravel implementation of the Model Context Protocol (MCP) SDK
This Laravel MCP SDK implementation exhibits significant gaps across definition quality dimensions. Of the 3 tools evaluated, only 2 are clearly defined in examples (greet, calculate); test_tool appears only in a test file with empty input schema. Tool descriptions are present but minimal (10-30 chars), far below the baseline of 194 chars for A+ tools. Parameter descriptions are brief and lack constraint details. No input schema validation, no output schema documentation, and no error recovery guidance. The tools lack type specificity in parameter documentation and fail to follow verb_noun naming conventions (names like 'greet' and 'calculate' are acceptable but descriptions don't explain WHEN to use them or what dependencies exist). Overall, this reads as a proof-of-concept SDK rather than production-grade tooling.
Performs basic arithmetic
Greets a person
A test tool
Tool descriptions critically under-specified. 'Greets a person' and 'Performs basic arithmetic' are 16-28 characters, far below the 50-200 char baseline for LLM-optimized descriptions. No guidance on WHEN to use each tool, dependencies, or state changes.
Parameter descriptions lack constraint details. 'First operand' and 'Second operand' don't explain valid ranges, formats, or error behavior. No mention of division-by-zero handling in the description, even though the code checks for it.
Output schema completely undocumented. Code returns {'status': 'success'|'error', 'message'|'result'} but this structure is not declared anywhere. LLMs cannot plan downstream calls without knowing what fields to expect.
Inferred effective spec: <=2025-11-25.
| Scored | Grade | Overall | Spec posture | Rubric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-22 | F | 34 | <=2025-11-25 | v2 |
No error recovery guidance. calculate() returns 'Cannot divide by zero' or 'Unknown operation' as bare strings in the result field. No indication to the LLM whether to retry, adjust input, or escalate.
test_tool has zero description and empty input schema {}. This tool is not production-ready and should either be completed or removed from the toolkit.
Parameter type naming inconsistent. 'operation' parameter accepts '+, -, *, /' but is not declared as an enum constraint. Free-form string invites hallucinated values like '**' (power) or 'mod'.
No composition or tool-chaining support documented. Tools are isolated examples; no guidance on how to combine them or what contextual information (e.g., user context, session state) the SDK assumes.