The server defines 5 tools with clear names and documented docstrings. All tools have proper input schemas with type definitions and parameter descriptions. Descriptions are adequate (60-200 chars) but generic, lacking specificity about when to use each tool or prerequisites. No output schemas are formally documented, return types are inferred from docstrings. Error handling is present in 2 tools (matrix_multiply, eigen_decomposition) but sparse. Tools follow a consistent verb_noun naming pattern, which aids discoverability. Security baseline met (no secrets in params, read-only operations). Composition is clean, each tool does one thing. However, the server lacks output schema documentation, lacks error recovery guidance, and descriptions do not indicate dependencies or use cases that would optimize LLM selection.
Add two numbers.
Compute eigenvalues and eigenvectors of a square matrix.
Multiply two matrices using NumPy.
Fit a polynomial to the given data points.
Perform statistical analysis on a dataset.
Output schemas not formally documented. Descriptions mention return types (e.g. 'List[List[float]]', 'dict[str, float]'), but no JSON Schema definitions are visible in tool registration. LLMs cannot reliably extract fields from unstructured return types and may misplan downstream tool calls.
Error recovery guidance missing. Only matrix_multiply and eigen_decomposition include exception handling with user-facing messages. The other 3 tools (add, statistical_analysis, polynomial_fit) have no visible error handling or recovery guidance. If input validation fails, LLMs receive raw exceptions and cannot self-correct.
Descriptions are generic and lack context for tool selection. 'Add two numbers' and 'Perform statistical analysis on a dataset' do not explain WHEN to use each tool or what makes it preferable to alternatives. Descriptions should indicate use cases, dependencies, and disambiguation hints.
| Scored | Grade | Overall | Spec posture | Rubric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-22 | D | 56 | 2026-07-28+ | v2 |
| 2026-03-09 | F | 44 | - | v1 |
Parameter constraints not fully specified. numeric parameters (degree in polynomial_fit, values in add/matrix_multiply) lack documented ranges or bounds. LLMs can pass invalid values (negative degree, extremely large matrices) without guidance on acceptable ranges.
No input validation logic visible for edge cases. E.g., polynomial_fit accepts degree with default=2 but does not validate that len(x) == len(y) or that degree < len(x). matrix_multiply does not validate that dimensions are compatible before attempting np.matmul. eigen_decomposition does not check that the matrix is square.