A very simple MCP server to explain who Roland is.
The roland server has a single tool 'about-roland' with critical definition quality gaps. The tool name does not follow verb_noun conventions (should be 'get_about_roland' or 'describe_roland'). The description is minimal (35 characters), providing no context about when to use this tool or what constitutes 'more information.' The input schema is completely empty (no parameters), which is acceptable for a read-only info tool but the schema itself lacks documentation. The output is returned as unstructured markdown text rather than structured fields, making it impossible for agents to extract specific details. There is no error handling documentation. This is a minimal hobby/demo server with no production-grade tool patterns applied.
Give more information about Roland
Tool name does not follow verb_noun convention. 'about-roland' should be 'get_about_roland' or 'describe_roland' to signal the action to LLMs.
Tool description is 35 characters (below 10-1024 baseline minimum of 34 but minimal for context). Provides no WHAT/WHEN/WHY guidance. Should explain: What specific information does this return? When should an agent call this instead of other discovery tools? What is the structure of the response?
Output is returned as plain markdown text ({type: 'text', text: about}) rather than structured fields. LLMs cannot extract specific details (e.g., job title, skills, contact info) without parsing unstructured markdown. Should return JSON object with typed fields like {name: string, role: string, bio: string, skills: string[]}.
| Scored | Grade | Overall | Spec posture | Rubric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-22 | F | 31 | 2026-07-28+ | v2 |
| 2026-03-09 | F | 16 | - | v1 |
No error handling. If the about.md file is missing, the server crashes with an unhandled promise rejection. Should catch file-not-found and return actionable error guidance to the LLM.
Hardcoded absolute file path in server.ts (/home/yoda/Development/Home/...) makes the server non-portable and breaks in any other deployment environment. Should use relative paths, environment variables, or a config file.