MCP server for Auth0 Management API integration, providing tools to manage Auth0 clients, forms, logs, and users
Mixed quality across 20 tools. Early tools (clients-*, forms-*, log-*) use imported parameter schemas from shared/parameters.js which are not visible in the provided source, preventing full validation of their schemas. Later tools (user-*, role-* tools) use inline Zod schemas with basic descriptions. Many tools lack adequate descriptions to guide LLM selection. No tool demonstrates rich error handling with recovery guidance. No tool annotations (readOnlyHint, destructiveHint, idempotentHint) present despite clear risk classifications. Output schemas are undocumented across all tools, LLMs cannot infer what fields to expect. Tool naming is inconsistent: 'clients-create' uses hyphen while 'create-user' uses dash; some tools lack verb-noun clarity (forms-create-all, log-get-by-id).
Assign roles to a user
Block a user from logging in
Delete a client by id.
Retrieve all clients.
Retrieve an individual client by id.
Create a new user in Auth0
8 tools (clients-*, forms-*, log-*) have NO VISIBLE INPUT SCHEMAS. Parameter schemas imported from shared/parameters.js are not provided in source code. Cannot verify schema completeness, type definitions, or parameter descriptions. Per HARD SCORING RULE, these tools must score 0 for schema component.
clients-create (first tool registered) has ZERO description. Per HARD SCORING RULE, description score must be 0. LLM cannot determine when or why to use this tool vs other client management tools. This violates pattern:tool-description baseline that 100% of A+ tools have docstrings.
NO TOOL HAS DOCUMENTED OUTPUT SCHEMAS. All 20 tools return generic `{content: [{type: 'text', text: JSON.stringify(...)}]}`. LLMs cannot infer what fields exist in the response, making downstream tool chaining unreliable. Response may contain user_id, id, or userId, LLM must guess which to use for next tool call. Violates pattern:tool baseline that 100% of A+ tools document return types.
| Scored | Grade | Overall | Spec posture | Rubric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-22 | D | 53 | 2026-07-28+ | v2 |
| 2026-03-09 | F | 41 | - | v1 |
Delete a user permanently
Find a user for a given email
Create a new form.
Retrieve all forms.
Retrieve a user by their Auth0 user ID
Retrieve a list of users with pagination
Retrieves the Tenant Logs based on the provided search criteria.
Retrieve an individual log event by id.
Remove roles from a user
Send an email verification email to a user
Unblock a previously blocked user
Update a user's details
Manually verify a user's email
NO TOOL ANNOTATIONS PRESENT. All 20 tools lack destructiveHint, readOnlyHint, or idempotentHint annotations. Tools clearly marked DESTRUCTIVE (clients-delete, delete-user) or WRITE risk (clients-create, create-user, block-user) should be annotated to guide agent planning and prevent accidental irreversible operations. This is a current MCP spec pattern (2026-07-28), not deprecated, but missing.
INCONSISTENT NAMING CONVENTION. Tools use both hyphen (clients-create, clients-delete) and dash (create-user, delete-user) separators. First 8 tools use resource_action naming (clients-get-all), later 12 use action_resource naming (create-user, delete-user). LLMs struggle with inconsistent naming patterns. Baseline: 90% of A+ tools use consistent verb_noun or consistent resource-action pattern.
WEAK ERROR HANDLING AND NO RECOVERY GUIDANCE. Tools return bare error strings like `Error: ${(error as Error).message}` (see find-user-by-email, get-user-by-id, create-user, etc.). No structured error classification (retryable, user-fixable, fatal). Error messages do not guide next steps. Per pattern:recovery-guide, agents need 'User not found. Try search_users() with a partial name.' Baseline baseline: A+ tools provide recovery guidance in errors.
MISSING PARAMETER TYPE DOCUMENTATION. update-user takes `data: z.record(z.string(), z.any())`, a catch-all object with no structure guidance. LLM cannot infer what fields are updateable (email? password? metadata?).
FORMS-CREATE-ALL AND LOG TOOLS LACK CLARITY. 'forms-create-all' naming is ambiguous, does it create multiple forms or one form with all configuration? 'log-get-all' and 'log-get-by-id' have no description of pagination limits. If 'log-get-all' returns thousands of log entries, context window explodes. Per pattern:paginated-result, tools returning lists must cap results and offer pagination, no tool documents this behavior.
TOOL COMPOSITION GAP: NO CHAINING SUPPORT. If create-user returns a user_id, can assign-role-to-user accept it directly? Can find-user-by-email return enough data for get-user-by-id to not be called again? Response fields are wrapped in generic 'text' JSON blobs, LLM cannot extract and chain IDs reliably. Per pattern:tool-chain, tool A's output must contain IDs tool B needs.
CLIENTS-CREATE EXPOSES UNSAFE DEFAULTS. Parameters like 'custom_login_page_on', 'sso', 'allow_origins' default to undefined/unset. Document and make defaults explicit.