A Flask-based web server providing REST APIs for managing a scoreboard with scores, tasks, and file tracking. Includes a web UI with automated functionality.
This MCP server has critical definition quality issues across the board. Tool names lack action verbs (only 3 of 9 start with verbs), descriptions are minimal (average 45 chars, well below the 194-char baseline), and input schemas lack proper type definitions and descriptions for most parameters. While the server implements basic HTTP endpoints and some schemas are present, the LLM cannot reliably infer intent from tool names alone, and parameter validation is insufficient. Output schemas are not documented. Error handling is absent, no guidance on retryability or recovery steps. This server would fail code review by production standards.
Add a new file path to the tracked files list
Add a new task to the scoreboard
Delete a task from the scoreboard by id
Retrieve the list of tracked files and current file
Retrieve the current score from the scoreboard
Retrieve all tasks from the scoreboard
Set the currently selected file
Update the score value in the scoreboard
Update an existing task in the scoreboard
Most tool names lack action verbs. 'get_score', 'get_tasks', 'get_files' are clear, but 'add_file' and 'set_current_file' are less descriptive than 'add_file_to_tracking' or 'select_current_file'. The passive names 'add_file' and 'set_current_file' do not strongly signal the action to an LLM.
Tool descriptions are critically short and vague. Average length 45 characters; baseline is 194. Example: 'Retrieve the current score from the scoreboard' (45 chars). No explanation of WHEN to use this tool, what dependencies exist, or what context it assumes. LLMs cannot reliably select the right tool from such sparse descriptions.
| Scored | Grade | Overall | Spec posture | Rubric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-22 | F | 49 | 2026-07-28+ | v2 |
| 2026-03-09 | F | 29 | - | v1 |
Parameters lack descriptions. Example: set_score has 'score' with type 'number' but no description of valid range, unit, or constraints. update_task has 'id' with no explanation of format or what identifies a task. add_task has 'status' as a string with no enum or allowed values documented. LLMs cannot infer constraints from names alone.
No enum constraints for status parameter. add_task and update_task both accept a 'status' string with no documented allowed values (code shows 'pending', 'in_progress', 'done'). Without an enum, LLMs will hallucinate invalid statuses like 'blocked', 'paused', etc.
Output schemas are not documented. No tool specifies what fields are returned, their types, or structure. Example: get_tasks returns 'tasks' array, but the description does not specify whether each task object includes 'id', 'name', 'status', or other fields. Agents cannot plan downstream chaining without knowing the response structure.
No error handling or recovery guidance. The Flask app returns HTTP 404 'Task not found' for update_task, but the tool description does not explain this error case or what the LLM should do next (e.g., call get_tasks to verify the id exists). Agents have no guidance on retryability.
Destructive operation (delete_task) has no confirmation step or dry-run mode. Agents can irreversibly delete tasks without warning. A confirmation_request pattern or undo_delete_task tool would prevent accidental data loss.
Parameter names are not human-centric. 'add_file' expects a 'file' parameter (string path), but the description does not indicate whether this is a local file path, URL, or URI. 'set_current_file' expects 'current_file', could be clearer as 'file_path' with explicit format guidance.
No pagination or limit handling for get_tasks and get_files. If the scoreboard grows to hundreds of tasks or files, these tools will return the entire list, bloating token usage and degrading LLM reasoning. No 'limit' or 'offset' parameters to support pagination.
No tool annotations (readOnlyHint, destructiveHint, idempotentHint) visible in tool definitions. The server registers tools with Flask routes, but no MCP protocol annotations are applied. This prevents clients and agents from understanding operation semantics at a glance.