This server has critical definition gaps across all dimensions. Tool names lack action verbs, descriptions are extremely minimal (3-20 chars), input schemas are present but parameter descriptions are generic or missing, and there is no documented output schema. None of the tools follow the verb_noun naming convention (e.g., 'MacOs Open App' should be 'open_app'). The server registers 4 tools but provides virtually no guidance to LLMs about when to use them, what they return, or what errors might occur. This is below production quality for agent deployment.
Find In App
Get Data
Input Message
MacOs Open App
Tool names do not follow verb_noun convention and lack action clarity. 'MacOs Open App' should be 'open_app'; 'GetData' should be 'get_data'; 'Find In App' should be 'find_in_app'; 'Input Message' should be 'input_message'. Current names are unclear about what action is performed.
All tool descriptions are under 20 characters ('Get Data', 'MacOs Open App', 'Find In App', 'Input Message'). These descriptions provide zero context about when to use the tool, what it modifies, or what it returns. LLMs cannot determine selection logic from these strings.
No output schemas documented. The rubric requires documentation of return types and output fields. LLMs need to know what GetData returns, what fields are in the result, and whether pagination is supported. All four tools lack this.
| Scored | Grade | Overall | Spec posture | Rubric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-22 | F | 13 | <=2025-11-25 | v2 |
| 2026-03-09 | F | 19 | - | v1 |
Parameter descriptions are minimal. 'keyword' is described only as 'search keyword' (15 chars). 'appName' is 'app name' (8 chars). 'appPath' is 'app path' (8 chars). 'message' is 'input message' (13 chars). These do not meet the 10-1024 character range for effective LLM guidance and contain no format constraints, examples, or dependency hints.
Three tools (MacOs Open App, Find In App, Input Message) are marked WRITE risk but have no error handling documentation, confirmation patterns, or recovery guidance. No guidance on what happens if app is not found or if input fails.
No input validation or constraint documentation. 'keyword' has no length limits. 'appName' and 'appPath' have no format constraints. 'message' has no length or content restrictions. Parameters accept arbitrary strings with no guidance on valid ranges or formats.
Tool naming inconsistency and lack of clarity about mutually exclusive tools. Both 'Find In App' and 'MacOs Open App' operate on applications but have overlapping concerns. The naming does not clarify the distinction or when to use each one.
GetData tool has no context about what kind of data is returned, what the search operates over, or whether pagination is supported. The single parameter 'keyword' is underspecified.