Downloads Warden provides 8 tools with basic parameter schemas and descriptions, but exhibits significant quality gaps. All tool names follow verb_noun convention (scan_, smart_sort_, sort_by_, deduplicate_, auto_extract_, clear_, find_), which is strong. However, descriptions are generic (10-100 chars, well below the 194 char baseline), parameters lack detailed constraints, and output schemas are entirely undocumented. The source reveals that tool implementations delegate to a container module (scan.execute, smart_sort.execute, etc.), but the actual return types and fields are not visible in the provided code. Parameter descriptions are minimal: 'Optional path to the Downloads folder; defaults to ~/Downloads' repeats across 8 tools without explaining validation rules, path traversal risks, or format requirements. The dry_run boolean on destructive tools is a strong pattern, but the lack of detailed error handling, permission gates, and output schema documentation keeps the score well below production baseline.

• Document return schemas for all 8 tools. For each, define the dict structure: e.g., scan_downloads_tool returns {"file_count": int, "total_size_bytes": int, "by_extension": {ext: count}, "categories": {cat: count}}. Include field types and descriptions.
• Enhance folder_path parameter description: 'Absolute path to target directory. Must exist and be readable. Defaults to ~/Downloads. Subject to sandbox validation, paths outside user home (or configured root) are rejected.'
• Add state-change warnings to tool descriptions. E.g., 'WARNING: This tool DELETES FILES. It removes duplicate files by hash. Always review dry_run=true output before running with dry_run=false.'
• Document error conditions and recovery paths for each tool. E.g., 'If FolderNotFoundError is returned, verify the path exists and is readable. Call scan_downloads_tool first to check folder status.'
• Split auto_extract_and_cleanup_tool into two tools: extract_archives_tool (extracts ZIPs, returns extracted paths) and delete_archive_sources_tool (deletes source archives). This enables agents to extract without auto-deletion if desired.
• Add numeric constraints to parameter descriptions: 'days_old (integer, 1-365, default 30): Installers older than this many days will be removed.' 'min_size_mb (integer, 1-10000, default 500): Report files larger than this many MB.'
• Implement structured error responses. Instead of raising raw exceptions, return {"success": false, "error": "folder_not_found", "path": "/path/to/folder", "recovery": "Call scan_downloads_tool to verify the folder exists."}

Inferred effective spec: <=2025-11-25.

• Relies on Logging (deprecated) - log to stderr or use OpenTelemetry