Single tool 'fetch-weather' has a clear verb-starting name and basic schema, but critical gaps undermine production readiness. Description is minimal (34 chars, below the 50-200 char ideal for LLM selection). Input schema is present and typed (city: string) with description, meeting basic requirements. However, no output schema is documented, the tool returns unstructured JSON from an external API without describing what fields the LLM should expect. Error handling returns plain text fallbacks without guidance on recovery or classification (retryable vs fatal). No validation of the city parameter, no handling of edge cases (empty string, invalid characters), and no result limits or pagination support. The tool lacks idempotency hints, permission gates, and security considerations. Overall structure is functional for a basic example but far below production grade.
Fetch the weather for a given city
No output schema documented. Tool returns raw JSON from external API without describing return structure, field types, or what the LLM should extract.
Description is only 34 characters ('Fetch the weather for a given city'). Below the 50-char minimum and missing critical context: when to use this vs alternatives, what format data returns in, any prerequisites or rate limits.
No input validation. The 'city' parameter accepts any string with no length limits, format constraints, or validation. Empty string, special characters, or extremely long city names are not rejected, they fail silently at the external API.
Error handling is generic and unhelpful to LLMs. Responses like 'Error processing request: <error.message>' provide no recovery guidance. Errors are not classified (retryable vs fatal). No distinction between 'city not found' and 'API timeout'.
| Scored | Grade | Overall | Spec posture | Rubric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-22 | F | 45 | 2026-07-28+ | v2 |
| 2026-03-09 | F | 36 | - | v1 |
No result limits or pagination. The tool fetches raw API response without capping result size, filtering fields, or documenting the response structure. Large responses could bloat context.
External API calls lack explicit timeout configuration. Long-running requests to geocoding or weather APIs could hang, blocking the agent.