MCP server providing access to Grokipedia knowledge base with intelligent search, content retrieval, and page metadata queries
Single tool with moderate structure but significant quality gaps. Tool name 'grokipedia_query' lacks a clear action verb and conflates multiple distinct operations (search, fetch, get-by-slug, get-content) into one tool, violating single-responsibility principle. Description is verbose (528 chars, well above 200-char production baseline) and relies on example values rather than formal constraints. Schema is present with typed parameters and defaults, but lacks descriptions for several critical parameters and does not document the output structure. No error handling guidance or recovery paths. No pagination support despite potentially large result sets.
🌟 All-in-one Grokipedia tool - your gateway to knowledge. This tool intelligently handles all Grokipedia queries in ONE call. Actions: - "smart" (default): Searches and automatically fetches full details for top results - "search": Just return search results with slugs (for browsing) - "page": Get specific page details with citations (requires slug) - "content": Get full text content of a page (requires slug)
Tool name 'grokipedia_query' lacks action verb and conflates 4 distinct operations (search, smart-fetch, get-by-slug, get-content) into one tool. Should be split into separate tools with clear verb_noun naming (e.g., search_grokipedia, get_grokipedia_page, get_grokipedia_content).
Parameter 'action' is free-form string with no enum constraint. Description lists valid values ('smart', 'search', 'page', 'content') as examples only. LLMs will hallucinate other action values. Must declare as enum with exact options.
Output schema is not documented. Tool returns JSON strings with varying structures depending on action (search_results, page_data, content_text). LLMs cannot predict response format or plan downstream operations.
Parameter descriptions are incomplete or missing. 'slug' parameter has no description of its format or source. 'query' has minimal guidance on expected input. 'max_results' lacks range constraints (what is min/max acceptable value?).
| Scored | Grade | Overall | Spec posture | Rubric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-22 | F | 45 | 2026-07-28+ | v2 |
| 2026-03-09 | F | 49 | - | v1 |
No pagination support. 'smart' mode fetches only top N results (default 2) but full search can return 11 results. No limit parameter exposed, no next_cursor or offset mechanism. Large result sets will bloat context window.
Error handling returns bare JSON objects with 'error' field but no guidance on recovery or retry strategy. E.g., 'Rate limit exceeded' response provides no retry-after hint or alternative action.
Tool description contains example invocations as literal strings (e.g., 'grokipedia_query("Albert Einstein")'), which LLMs may reuse verbatim. Use formal enum/pattern constraints instead.
Parameter 'slug' is marked optional with no description of its relationship to 'action'. The action 'page' and 'content' REQUIRE slug; others ignore it. Undocumented dependencies cause silent misuse.