Model Context Protocol SDK for Client and Server applications in PHP
Symfony MCP SDK provides a single example tool ('Current time') with complete schema, clear description, and proper interface implementation. The tool demonstrates good structure with MetadataInterface and ToolExecutorInterface separation. However, the server is primarily an SDK/framework rather than a production MCP server with multiple tools. The single example tool is well-implemented but limited in scope. Tool names are action-oriented but lack the context of a multi-tool system. No evidence of batch operations, pagination patterns, or complex composition scenarios typical of production-grade servers. Error handling is minimal, ToolCallResult.php shows basic structure but lacks recovery guidance. Output schema is not documented (getOutputSchema() returns null), violating the documented output pattern.
Returns the current time in UTC
Output schema not documented. ToolCallResult returns generic string with type/mimeType fields, but getOutputSchema() returns null. LLM cannot infer structure of the returned DateTime string or validate formatting.
Parameter 'format' lacks practical constraints and examples in schema. Description says 'e.g. Y-m-d H:i:s' but does not specify allowed format codes, character limits, or validation rules. LLM could pass invalid PHP date format strings.
No error handling guidance. ToolExecutionException and ToolNotFoundException are declared but never documented in the tool definition. LLM has no recovery hints if format is invalid or tool fails.
Tool annotations interface present but unused. getAnnotations() returns null for example tool. readOnlyHint should be true, destructiveHint should be false, idempotentHint should be true, these properties would help LLM reasoning about retry safety.
Inferred effective spec: 2025-06-18+.
| Scored | Grade | Overall | Spec posture | Rubric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-22 | D | 55 | 2025-06-18+ | v2 |
Single example tool limits assessment of composition patterns. No evidence of tool chaining, pagination, batch operations, or multi-step workflows. SDK is framework-focused, not production-server focused.