MCP server for IP and geolocation functionality deployed on Railway using FastMCP 3.0
This server has only one tool with severe quality gaps. The tool 'get_my_ip' has a trivial description (33 characters, below the 50-char baseline for minimal functionality), no input parameters defined (empty input schema), and no documented output schema. The description does not explain what the tool actually does (it claims to verify connectivity, but does not describe the return value or use case). No parameters means no parameter descriptions or validation. The tool violates the single-responsibility principle by conflating connectivity verification with IP retrieval. No error handling, no recovery guidance, and no security or composition considerations are evident. This is below-average for a production tool.
Returns a success message to verify connectivity.
No input schema defined. Tool has empty input object {}. Per hard scoring rule, schema score MUST be 0 when no schema is visible.
Description is only 33 characters ('Returns a success message to verify connectivity.'). Below the 50-char baseline minimum. Does not answer: What does it return? What is the output format? When should the LLM call it?
No output schema documented. Callers do not know what type or structure to expect from the return value.
Tool name 'get_my_ip' is ambiguous. It does not clearly distinguish between retrieving the client's IP address vs. verifying server connectivity. The description claims connectivity verification, but the name implies IP retrieval. Mismatch confuses LLMs.
| Scored | Grade | Overall | Spec posture | Rubric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-22 | F | 35 | 2026-07-28+ | v2 |
| 2026-03-09 | F | 21 | - | v1 |
No error handling, recovery guidance, or categorization. If the tool fails, the LLM has no actionable error message or next steps.
Tool does not follow the verb_noun naming convention clearly. 'get_my_ip' is unclear, does it return the user's IP, the server's IP, or a connectivity status?