The weather server defines 2 tools with basic functionality but has significant quality gaps. Both tools have names that start with action verbs (get_alerts, get_forecast), which is good. However, descriptions are minimal (under 100 chars for both), and parameter descriptions lack detail about formats, constraints, and expected ranges. Input schemas are present but incomplete, parameters lack type constraints like enums or ranges. Output is formatted as plain text strings rather than structured objects, making it difficult for agents to parse and compose with other tools. Error responses are generic strings (e.g., 'Unable to fetch alerts!', 'No Data Found') without guidance on what to do next. No tool annotations, no pagination support, and no documented output schemas. Both tools are idempotent reads, which is safe, but the interface is optimized for display rather than agent composition.
Get the weather alerts for a given state
Get the forecast for a given location
Tool descriptions are too brief (under 100 characters) and lack context on when to use each tool, prerequisites, and return value structure.
Parameter 'state' in get_alerts has no constraints. Should be an enum of valid US state codes or a regex pattern. Parameter 'latitude' and 'longitude' lack range constraints (e.g., latitude -90 to 90). Unconstrained parameters invite hallucinated values.
Tool outputs are unstructured plain text strings. Agents cannot parse structured data (e.g., alert severity, forecast temperature as a number) for downstream composition. Should return JSON objects with typed fields (e.g., alerts array with event, area, severity, description fields; forecast array with period, temperature, windSpeed as numbers).
| Scored | Grade | Overall | Spec posture | Rubric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-22 | F | 43 | 2026-07-28+ | v2 |
| 2026-03-09 | F | 39 | - | v1 |
Error messages are generic and do not guide recovery. 'Unable to fetch alerts!' and 'No Data Found' give no guidance on whether to retry, check inputs, or try an alternative. Should include actionable next steps, e.g., 'Invalid state code. Valid codes are: AL, AK, AZ, ... (50 US states). Did you mean: CA?'
No pagination support. If get_alerts returns many active alerts, the response could be very large. Tool description does not mention any result limits or pagination parameters.
Output schemas are not documented. Code comments mention response structure (e.g., 'properties' contains metadata), but LLMs have no formal schema to know what fields to expect. Should document return type as structured JSON with typed fields.
No tool annotations (readOnlyHint, destructiveHint, idempotentHint) declared. Both tools are read-only and safe to retry, but LLMs cannot infer this without explicit hints.