This is a web-accessible search tool that will look up information on the web to answer the question or search query. Call search() to search the web.
The 'search' tool has a single clear responsibility and action-verb naming (search_), which is good. However, the implementation reveals significant gaps in production-readiness: the description is present but generic (104 chars), the schema is basic with only one string parameter, output structure is undocumented, and error handling is entirely absent. The tool delegates to OpenAI's gpt-4o-search-preview model without validating inputs, handling failures, or guiding recovery. For a search tool that depends on an external API, this is a critical omission.
The search query meant to search on the internet. Can be a question, "What is the address of acme?" Can be an instruction, "Find documentation about this python library."
No error handling or recovery guidance. The tool calls OpenAI's API without try/catch, timeout handling, or validation. If the API fails, the LLM receives an unstructured Python exception rather than an actionable error message (e.g., 'Search failed due to API timeout. Try again with a simpler query.').
Output schema is undocumented. The function returns response.choices[0].message.content (a string), but the LLM has no formal schema describing the response structure. If the tool ever returns multiple results, references, metadata, or errors, the LLM cannot reliably parse them.
No input validation. The 'query' parameter is a free-form string with no length limit, format constraint, or minimum requirement. LLMs could pass empty strings, extremely long queries, or prompt-injection payloads without validation.
| Scored | Grade | Overall | Spec posture | Rubric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-23 | C | 64 | 2026-07-28+ | v2 |
No timeout or rate limiting. A long-running or malformed query could block the MCP server indefinitely. External API calls should have explicit timeouts.
API key is injected via environment variable (correct), but there is no validation that OPENAI_API_KEY is present at startup. A missing key will cause a runtime error on the first search() call rather than failing fast at initialization.