Loading ToolBench
ExpenseTracker has reasonable naming and complete schemas for all 12 tools, but descriptions are sparse and lack critical guidance for LLM selection. Parameter descriptions exist but are minimal (10-30 chars). Error handling returns status codes but lacks recovery guidance. No tool annotations (destructiveHint, idempotentHint, readOnlyHint) despite having a mix of READ_ONLY, REVERSIBLE, WRITE, and DESTRUCTIVE operations. The server lacks pagination for list results despite storing expenses in a growing database. Output schemas are implicit rather than documented.
Add an expense to the tracker
Check if spending exceeds budget limit
Calculate the average daily spending within a date range
Delete an expense
Export expenses to a CSV file
Check the health status of the server
List all expenses within a date range
Missing tool annotations (destructiveHint, idempotentHint, readOnlyHint) despite risk field metadata in spec. Tools like delete_expense (DESTRUCTIVE) and update_expense (REVERSIBLE) should be explicitly annotated for LLM decision-making.
Tool descriptions are extremely terse (13-45 characters). E.g., 'Add an expense to the tracker' lacks context on date format, category validation, or when to use this vs bulk import.
Inferred effective spec: <=2025-11-25.
| Scored | Grade | Overall | Spec posture | Rubric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-23 | C | 64 | <=2025-11-25 | v2 |
Generate a monthly expense report
Read an expense by ID
Summarize expenses by category within a date range
Get the top spending categories within a date range
Update an expense
list_expenses, summarize, and top_spending_categories have no pagination or result limits documented. As the expense database grows, returning all matching rows will blow context windows. Should accept limit/offset params and return total_count or next_cursor.
Error responses return generic status/error fields without recovery guidance. E.g., 'Invalid expense' tells LLM nothing about whether to retry, ask user, or skip. Should include classification (retryable/user-fixable/fatal) and actionable next step.
No dry-run or confirmation pattern for irreversible operations (delete_expense, export_csv). Agents should be able to preview consequences before committing destructive actions.
Parameter descriptions lack format constraints. E.g., 'Date in YYYY-MM-DD format' is mentioned in schema but 'start_date' and 'end_date' descriptions are vague. Should state: 'ISO 8601 date (YYYY-MM-DD, required)', 'Category must be one of: [list] or custom string', 'Limit must be 1-100 (default 3)'.
monthly_report has broken logic: constructs month-end dates with hardcoded '31' (e.g., '2024-02-31'), which will fail for February. Should use calendar module to compute actual month-end or document as accepting year/month only and computing correct range internally.
export_csv does not handle empty data set gracefully. Calls list_expenses which may return error or empty list; accessing data[0].keys() will crash if list_expenses returns empty. Should validate data before writing CSV and return actionable error.
Output schemas are implicit/undocumented. Tool responses return dicts like {status, id}, {status, error}, or raw result rows, but no formal schema is declared in tool metadata. LLMs cannot predict response structure and must infer from examples.
delete_expense provides no confirmation mechanism. Agents could accidentally delete all expenses in a loop. Should require explicit confirmation or return a preview of what will be deleted.