A goal decomposition service that breaks down high-level goals into structured subtasks and planning steps
This is a minimal proof-of-concept tool with critical deficiencies across naming, description, and schema quality. The single tool 'decompose_goal' has a basic description but lacks proper input/output schema documentation, parameter descriptions, and error handling. The implementation is purely stateless logic with no MCP server scaffolding visible, it appears to be a standalone Python client class, not an MCP server. No tool registration, no schema validation, no error guidance. This would not function as a production MCP server.
Decomposes a high-level goal into structured subtasks and planning steps
No MCP server transport detected, source shows only a Python client class (SuperAgentGoalPlannerClient), not an MCP server implementation. Cannot determine if STDIO, HTTP, or SSE is used.
Tool description is 88 characters (below rubric baseline of 194 chars avg, p10=34). Lacks WHEN to use, prerequisites, and expected return structure. LLMs cannot disambiguate this from other planning tools.
Input schema visible but output schema is NOT documented. Method returns {'subtask_plan': [...], 'estimated_steps': N} but no type declarations, field descriptions, or structure hints for the agent.
Parameter 'high_level_goal' has a description (88 chars) but lacks format constraints, length limits, or examples of valid vs invalid inputs. Description does not explain what 'decomposed' means or what subtasks look like.
| Scored | Grade | Overall | Spec posture | Rubric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-23 | F | 35 | 2026-07-28+ | v2 |
No error handling visible. Implementation naively splits on whitespace and hardcodes 5 steps. No validation, no recovery guidance, no explanation of what happens if input is empty, null, or malformed.
Tool logic is a hardcoded stub: returns identical 5-step plan regardless of goal complexity. Does not actually decompose, just generates placeholder text. Not usable by agents expecting meaningful task breakdown.