A feedback layer skill that processes user feedback (rating scores and text corrections) and generates revised prompt instructions for output refinement.
This server has a single tool 'parse_feedback' with critical definition gaps. The tool name lacks a clear action verb and is vague about what 'parse' produces. The input schema is present but minimal, three parameters with basic types. The description is present (63 chars) but lacks context on when/why to call this tool, what downstream effects occur, and how the output integrates with agent workflows. Parameters are typed but lack depth: 'rating_score' has no range constraints; 'text_correction' is a free-form string with no format guidance. No output schema is documented, the LLM cannot predict the return structure or chain to downstream tools. Error handling is absent. The tool is READ_ONLY (no side effects) but the implementation is too thin for production use, it concatenates a string template rather than performing substantive feedback processing. No security or composition patterns are evident. This server reads like a prototype rather than a production tool.
Processes user feedback (rating score and text corrections) and generates revised prompt instructions for output refinement.
Tool name 'parse_feedback' lacks action verb clarity. 'Parse' is vague, does it validate, transform, analyze, or store feedback? A name like 'generate_revised_prompt' or 'process_user_feedback' would be clearer. The LLM cannot infer the semantic action from 'parse_feedback' alone.
Input parameter 'rating_score' (integer) has no range constraints. Valid range should be documented (e.g., 1 - 5, 1 - 10). Without bounds, LLMs may pass absurd values ( - 999, 1000000) that break downstream logic or comparisons (e.g., the hardcoded < 4 check assumes 1 - 5 scale).
No output schema documented. The implementation returns {'revised_prompt_instructions': instruction}, but the LLM has no way to know this structure. Missing: field names, types, whether the response can fail, what the 'instruction' string contains. Without a schema, agents cannot reliably chain this tool output to other tools.
| Scored | Grade | Overall | Spec posture | Rubric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-23 | F | 40 | 2026-07-28+ | v2 |
Description lacks WHEN/WHY context. Current: 'Processes user feedback (rating score and text corrections) and generates revised prompt instructions for output refinement.' This describes the input/output but not the agent's decision logic: When should the LLM call this vs. other tools? What happens if rating_score >= 4 (returns 'Keep as is')? The description does not guide tool selection.
No error handling. The implementation assumes all inputs are valid and always returns a dict. What if 'original_output_id' does not exist? What if 'rating_score' is out of expected range? No error classification (retryable, user-fixable, fatal) or recovery guidance for the agent.
Parameter 'text_correction' is a free-form string with no format guidance. Is it plain text, Markdown, JSON, or something else? What length is acceptable? What characters are invalid? The LLM cannot optimize the input without explicit constraints.
Tool implementation is trivial, it only concatenates string templates based on a simple threshold (rating_score < 4). No actual feedback processing, validation, or state management. This appears to be a stub or POC, not production-ready.