Single tool with adequate schema but weak descriptions and no error guidance. Tool name lacks action verb (calcular_veredito is Portuguese for 'calculate verdict' but not verb_noun English convention). Description is 280+ chars, exceeds 200-char baseline for LLM optimization. Parameters have types (integer) and descriptions, but lack constraints (min/max 1-5 not enforced in schema). No output schema documented, return type is string with unstructured markdown. No error handling guidance; generic exception catch returns raw error text. Prompt feature present but not evaluated here.
Calcula o veredito final baseado nos scores parciais (1-5), aplicando pesos e penalidades lógicas. Pesos: Alucinação (40%), Precisão (30%), Completude (15%), Clareza (15%). Penalidades Críticas: - Se Alucinação <= 2 (Muita Alucinação): Score Final travado em 2.0 (Reprovado). - Se Precisão <= 2 (Incorreto): Score Final travado em 2.5 (Reprovado).
Tool name does not follow verb_noun convention. 'calcular_veredito' (Portuguese) should be 'calculate_verdict' or similar in English. LLMs rely on action verbs to infer intent.
Input parameters lack min/max constraints in schema. Integers are declared but 1-5 range is only documented in description text. JSON Schema should include 'minimum': 1, 'maximum': 5 to prevent invalid LLM inputs.
No output schema documented. Tool returns unstructured markdown string. LLMs cannot parse fields reliably. Should return structured JSON with score_base, score_final, verdict_text, penalty_applied fields.
Error handling provides no recovery guidance. Generic 'Erro no cálculo: {error}' string gives LLM no actionable next step. Should categorize errors (invalid range, calculation failure) and suggest retry or parameter correction.
| Scored | Grade | Overall | Spec posture | Rubric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-23 | F | 47 | 2026-07-28+ | v2 |
Tool description exceeds 200-char LLM optimization baseline (280+ chars). Verbose penalty logic explanation should be condensed; detailed rules belong in parameter descriptions or a separate reference.