A Chrome extension that injects a WebMCP tool (check_seller_policy) into e-commerce pages to provide risk assessment and buyer protection ratings for sellers before purchase.
Single tool 'check_seller_policy' has a well-written description (250+ chars, exceeds baseline 194 avg) and clear use case. However, the input schema is severely underspecified: both parameters are optional with no type constraints, enums, or validation rules. The schema lacks a documented output structure entirely, no return type, fields, or format guidance for the LLM. Parameter descriptions exist but lack format/constraint details (e.g., what constitutes a valid seller_url? What policy_text length is acceptable?). No error handling guidance. Tool is read-only (good), but lacks the rigor expected for production use.
Analyze a seller's policies to provide a risk assessment and buyer protection rating before purchase. Returns risk scores (0-10), detected risk factors (binding arbitration, no-refund clauses, restocking fees, liability caps), buyer protection rating (A+ to F), and a plain-language summary. Use this tool BEFORE completing any e-commerce purchase to verify seller trustworthiness. This is a read-only verification tool with no side effects — it only provides intelligence.
Input schema lacks type constraints and validation rules. Both parameters are optional with no format, length, or pattern guidance. 'seller_url' should specify URL format; 'policy_text' should specify max length and encoding.
Output schema is completely undocumented. No return type, field definitions, or structure guidance. LLM cannot plan downstream actions or extract risk scores, factors, or ratings without seeing the response shape.
No error handling guidance. Tool description does not explain what happens on invalid URLs, network failures, or unparseable policy text. LLM has no recovery path.
Parameter descriptions lack actionable constraints. 'seller_url' description does not specify URL format (http/https required?), domain restrictions, or what happens if URL is unreachable. 'policy_text' lacks max length, encoding, or language expectations.
| Scored | Grade | Overall | Spec posture | Rubric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-23 | F | 44 | 2026-07-28+ | v2 |
Tool name 'check_seller_policy' is acceptable but generic. Does not clearly distinguish from similar tools (e.g., 'analyze_seller_policy', 'verify_seller_policy'). Verb is clear but noun is broad.