Loading ToolBench
A local collaboration system for multi-role project management with workspace configuration, provider management, task tracking, reviews, and real-time event streaming
Critical failures across naming, descriptions, and schemas. Tool names lack action verbs (detect_all, public_payload, loadProject, refreshDashboard). Descriptions are present but generic (avg ~60 chars, well below 194-char baseline). Input schemas visible for ~15 tools but many lack type definitions or parameter descriptions. Output schemas entirely undocumented. No error handling guidance. Security concerns: tools accept file paths and execute commands without validation. Composition issues: tools like applySetup combine 8 concerns (mode, role, sync, trust, defaults, companion, workspace). No pagination, no idempotency markers, no recovery guidance.
Acknowledges a message as read
Applies project configuration including mode, role selection, and workspace settings
Confirms and executes the planned environment installation
Continues the onboarding process to the next stage
Creates a new project instance at the specified target root directory
Creates a new task in the project
Makes a decision on a review request (approve/reject)
Detects all available tools and environments in the system
Tool names lack action verbs. 'detect_all', 'public_payload', 'loadProject', 'refreshDashboard' do not clearly signal intent. LLMs cannot infer whether to call them without reading full descriptions.
No output schemas documented. Tools return data but LLMs cannot plan downstream calls or extract fields. E.g., detect_all returns 'detected environment data' but structure is unknown.
applySetup combines 8 concerns (mode, role, sync, trust, defaults, companion, workspace). Should split into separate tools: set_project_mode, select_roles, sync_environment, write_trust_config, etc.
| Scored | Grade | Overall | Spec posture | Rubric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-23 | F | 31 | 2026-07-28+ | v2 |
Performs a failover of a role to an alternative provider
Executes the installation plan for specified targets with signature verification
Loads a project from the specified project root directory
Loads detailed information for a specific review
Loads detailed information for a specific task
Loads the timeline of events for a specific task
Loads all messages in a conversation thread
Performs a failover operation for a selected role to a selected provider
Performs a specific onboarding action
Plans the installation of an environment target with dependency resolution
Plans the installation of specified targets with dependency resolution and execution preview
Previews what would happen if a configuration change is rolled back
Converts detected environment data into a public payload format
Refreshes the project dashboard with latest data
Refreshes the environment detection and reports available tools
Requests a review for a task
Rolls back a configuration change to a previous state
Executes a project action such as verify-workspace, up, restore, status, doctor, or provider failover
Selects an event for detailed viewing
Sends a message between roles in the project
Shuts down the GUI server
Updates mode configurations for different scopes and fields
Updates a provider configuration field value
Updates an existing task with new values
Updates workspace configuration including window title and pane settings
Path traversal and command injection risks. Tools accept 'projectRoot', 'targetRoot', and 'extraArgs' without validation. Malicious paths or shell metacharacters could escape sandboxes.
No error recovery guidance. Tools lack descriptions of failure modes, retryability, or next steps. E.g., 'install_targets' can fail if plan signature changes, but no guidance on how to recover.