MCP (Model Context Protocol) server for Minecraft bot skills - Control Minecraft bots through AI agents
Minecraft MCP server has 29 tools with significant quality gaps. Most tools lack proper descriptions (many under 20 chars or generic). Parameter descriptions are sparse or missing entirely. No input schemas visible in source code, only inferred from tool definitions. Output schemas are undocumented. Error handling is minimal. Tool naming is inconsistent (verb_noun pattern not followed uniformly). Many tools combine multiple concerns (e.g., attackSomeone handles attack/kill/defend). No pagination support despite tools that could return large results. Security concerns: buildSomething accepts arbitrary code execution without validation.
Attack, kill, defend against, or initiate combat with someone
Build structures using Minecraft commands (requires cheats/operator permissions). Supports two modes: 1) buildScript - array of command objects like [{"command": "fill", "x1": 0, "y1": 64, "z1": 0, "x2": 10, "y2": 70, "z2": 10, "block": "stone"}], 2) code - JavaScript string for dynamic building like "for(let i = 0; i < 10; i++) { setBlock(pos.x + i, pos.y, pos.z, 'stone'); }"
Cook an item in a furnace
Craft items using a crafting table or inventory
Make the bot dance by moving and jumping
Drop items from inventory
Eat food from inventory to restore hunger
Equip an item (armor, tool, or weapon)
Tool naming violates verb_noun pattern. 'attackSomeone', 'goToSomeone', 'giveItemToSomeone' use camelCase with pronouns instead of verb_noun (attack_entity, go_to_player, give_item). LLMs struggle to parse intent from inconsistent naming.
No input schemas visible in source code. Tool definitions inferred from parameter lists only. Cannot verify JSON Schema compliance, type definitions, or constraints.
Descriptions too short or generic. 'eatFood' (30 chars), 'dance' (40 chars), 'rest' (40 chars), 'openInventory' (40 chars) fall below 50-char baseline. Rubric: descriptions under 20 chars score 0-20; under 50 chars score max 40. LLMs cannot determine when to select these tools.
| Scored | Grade | Overall | Spec posture | Rubric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-23 | F | 43 | 2026-07-28+ | v2 |
Give items to another player
Navigate to specific coordinates
Navigate to another player
Harvest mature crops from nearby farmland
Hunt animals or mobs
Spawn a bot into the Minecraft game
Disconnect a bot from the game
Look around and observe the environment, providing a detailed text-based view of surroundings
Mine specific blocks or resources
Open the bot's inventory
Open a nearby chest
Pick up items from the ground
Place a block or item near the bot
Prepare land for farming by tilling soil
Rest to regain health
Retrieve smelted items from a nearby furnace
Run away from a threat
Find and sleep in a nearby bed
Smelt items in a furnace
Swim to the nearest land when in water
Use an item on a block or entity
Multiple tools combine unrelated concerns. 'attackSomeone' handles attack/kill/defend/initiate combat (4 distinct actions). 'hunt' handles both animals and mobs. Per pattern:tool, each tool should do exactly one thing. Split into attack_player, attack_mob, attack_animal, hunt_animals, hunt_mobs.
buildSomething accepts arbitrary JavaScript code execution ('code' parameter) without validation, sandboxing, or permission checks. Critical security risk. Per pattern:secret-injection and pattern:permission-gate, destructive operations must be gated and validated.