A video analysis system with MCP servers for video processing and transcription, integrated with a Tauri desktop application and Python backend using gRPC
Both tools have identical, generic descriptions ('Upload a local file to http.') that fail to distinguish their purpose or when to use each. Input schemas are minimal, only local_file_path with basic string type, no format/pattern constraints. No output schema documented. Parameter descriptions are trivial. No error handling guidance. Tool names suggest different targets (HTTP vs Gradio) but descriptions don't clarify. upload_files_to_gradio is a wrapper around upload_to_http, violating single-responsibility principle. No idempotency guarantees, no rate limiting, no permission checks. Code shows potential path traversal risk in _in_asset_folder() (undefined asset_dir_path variable) and multipart parsing vulnerabilities.
Upload a local file to http.
Upload a local file to http.
Identical generic descriptions for two distinct tools. Both say 'Upload a local file to http.' but upload_files_to_gradio targets Gradio specifically. LLM cannot distinguish when to use each.
No output schema documented. Tools return a string URL but LLM has no formal schema to parse or validate the response structure.
Parameter description is trivial ('The local file path.') with no format constraints, validation rules, or examples. No mention of supported file types, size limits, or path requirements.
upload_files_to_gradio is a thin wrapper that delegates to upload_to_http, violating single-responsibility principle. Composition is broken, two tools doing the same thing confuse LLM decision-making.
| Scored | Grade | Overall | Spec posture | Rubric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-23 | F | 29 | 2026-07-28+ | v2 |
Code contains security vulnerabilities: _in_asset_folder() references undefined variable 'asset_dir_path' (should be ASSET_FOLDER_PATH), and multipart form parsing is naive, no boundary validation, no filename sanitization, no path traversal checks. Agents could upload to arbitrary locations.