Single tool 'get_docs' has a verb-based name (good), but the description is overly long (194 chars) and includes example values ('Chroma DB', 'LangChain') that LLMs may reuse literally. Input schema is present with types and descriptions, but lacks enums for the 'library' parameter despite supporting only 3 known values (langchain, llama-index, openai). No output schema is documented, the tool returns unstructured text rather than structured objects. Error handling returns plain strings instead of actionable recovery guidance. The tool combines search + fetch operations, violating single-responsibility principle.
Search the docs for a given query and libraries Support langchain, openAI and llama-index. Args: query: The query to search for (eg: "Chroma DB") library: The library to search in (eg: "LangChain") Returns: List of dictionaries containing source URLs and exracted text
No output schema documented. Tool returns raw text concatenation instead of structured objects with typed fields (e.g., {url, title, content, source}). LLMs cannot plan downstream operations or extract specific data.
Library parameter accepts free-form strings instead of enum constraint. Should declare library as enum: ['langchain', 'llama-index', 'openai']. Current implementation silently fails with 'Library X not supported' instead of guiding LLM to valid options.
Description includes example values ('Chroma DB', 'LangChain') that LLMs tend to reuse literally in subsequent calls. Should replace with enum constraint and remove examples from description text.
Error responses are plain strings ('Error: ...', 'No Results Found') without recovery guidance. Should return structured errors with actionable next steps, e.g., 'No results found. Try a broader query or check library name is one of: langchain, llama-index, openai'.
| Scored | Grade | Overall | Spec posture | Rubric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-23 | F | 43 | 2026-07-28+ | v2 |
Tool combines two concerns: web search + page fetching. Should split into search_docs (returns URLs + snippets) and fetch_doc_content (retrieves full text). Enables agent to compose and retry independently.