A wine database server providing wine search and retrieval capabilities via HTTP endpoints
Two tools with minimal definitions. Both have verb-noun naming (get_wines, search_wines) which is correct. However, descriptions are extremely brief (18-24 chars, well below the 50-200 char baseline for A+ tools). Input schemas are present but sparse: get_wines has empty input {}, search_wines has one parameter 'q' with type and description. No output schemas documented. No error handling guidance. No parameter constraints (e.g., max query length). Tools are read-only but lack explicit idempotent/readOnly annotations. Overall structure is functional but falls short of production quality.
Retrieve all wines from the database
Search wines by query string across name, cn_name, region, grapes, notes, pairing, and agent_tags fields
Descriptions are critically short (18-24 chars). Baseline for A+ tools is 50-200 chars. LLMs cannot determine when/why to select tools with such minimal context.
No output schemas documented. LLMs cannot plan downstream calls or extract required fields (e.g., wine IDs for follow-up operations) without knowing response structure.
No pagination support. get_wines returns all items unbounded; search_wines has no limit/offset. Large result sets will exhaust context windows and degrade LLM reasoning.
Missing tool annotations. Both tools are read-only but lack readOnlyHint annotation. Agents cannot distinguish safe tools from destructive ones without explicit hints.
| Scored | Grade | Overall | Spec posture | Rubric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-23 | F | 45 | 2026-07-28+ | v2 |
No error handling guidance. If search fails or database is unavailable, LLM receives no recovery instructions. No distinction between retryable vs fatal errors.