MCP server that generates synthetic room impulse responses from plain-language descriptions, for sound design and convolution.
Single tool with well-structured schema, comprehensive parameter descriptions, and proper tool annotations. Naming is clear (generate_room_ir). Descriptions are detailed and actionable (194 chars for tool, 50-100 chars per param). All 7 parameters have type definitions and descriptions. Output is documented via _format() function. Main gaps: no explicit error handling guidance, no pagination/limits (though single-call tool), and output schema not formally documented in code.
Simulate a room and write a stereo impulse response WAV for convolution reverb. Returns a summary and the file path. Translate the space the user described into dimensions and an absorption coefficient, following the guidance on each argument. Omitted arguments are randomised. Repeated calls vary even with identical arguments, so call again to get a different take on the same room.
Output schema not formally documented. Tool returns a formatted string; LLMs cannot parse structured fields (dimensions, absorption, duration, path) without seeing the format spec.
No error handling guidance. Tool can fail (invalid dimensions, file write errors, pyroomacoustics simulation failures) but descriptions do not explain recovery steps or error categories.
Numeric parameters (width_m, length_m, height_m, absorption) lack explicit min/max bounds in schema. Descriptions mention ranges but JSON Schema should enforce DIM_BOUNDS (0.5 - 40.0) and ABSORPTION_BOUNDS (0.02 - 0.95) via minimum/maximum fields.
mic_position and source_position accept free-form strings with fallback to random. Should be enums ('center', 'corner', 'near_wall') to prevent hallucinated values and self-document valid options.
| Scored | Grade | Overall | Spec posture | Rubric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-23 | C | 63 | 2026-07-28+ | v2 |
Tool is non-idempotent by design ('Repeated calls vary even with identical arguments'). Descriptions acknowledge this, but no guidance on when/why to retry or how agents should handle variance.