Two tools with minimal schema rigor and weak descriptions. about_me has empty input schema ({}), violating schema requirements. contact has proper parameter types but descriptions lack actionable detail. Both descriptions are generic and under 200 chars. No error handling guidance, no output schema documentation, no parameter constraints (enums, ranges). Tool names lack clear verb-noun structure ('about_me' is vague; 'contact' is ambiguous, send? receive?). No security considerations documented despite contact being a WRITE operation that sends external messages.
Get personal information about the user. Returns: dict: Personal information requested
Send a message to the user. If the user has not specified a sender email, subject, or message, ask them for those details before continuing. Do NOT use sample or example email addresses. You must explicitly ask the user for these details if they are not provided. If you do not have the correct information provided by the user, you must NOT use this tool and should inform the user of the reason why.
about_me tool has empty input schema ({}). Tool provides no parameters but also no documentation of what it returns or when to call it.
contact tool description lacks actionable error guidance. Does not explain what happens on webhook failure, invalid email, or network timeout. LLM has no recovery path.
Tool names are ambiguous. 'about_me' does not start with action verb (should be 'get_personal_info' or 'retrieve_about_me'). 'contact' is vague, does it send, receive, or list contacts? Naming violates verb_noun convention.
No output schema documented for either tool. about_me returns 'dict: Personal information requested' (generic). contact returns 'dict: Status of the message delivery' (generic). LLM cannot plan downstream calls or extract specific fields.
| Scored | Grade | Overall | Spec posture | Rubric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-23 | F | 39 | 2026-07-28+ | v2 |
contact tool exposes security risk: webhook_url loaded from config.json without validation. No rate limiting, no input sanitization against injection attacks. Credentials (webhook URL) should not be in config file accessible to tool code.