Automatically creates an MCP server based on the instructions
Single tool 'create_mcp_server' has a clear action verb and acceptable description (89 chars), but critical gaps undermine quality. Input schema is present with 3 parameters, all typed as strings with descriptions. However, the tool performs a WRITE operation (creates directories, installs software, modifies filesystem) with NO error recovery guidance, NO confirmation step, and NO idempotency markers. The description does not warn about side effects or prerequisites (uv installation, disk space). Output is unstructured text rather than a typed response object. No parameter validation constraints (e.g., project_name format, location path validation). The tool invokes subprocess commands without sanitization, creating injection risks. Missing: enum constraints, output schema documentation, destructive operation warnings, and recovery guidance for partial failures.
Automatically creates an MCP server based on the instructions.
No confirmation or dry-run for destructive operations. Tool creates directories, installs software, and modifies filesystem without user confirmation. Agents can trigger irreversible side effects.
Output is unstructured plain text instead of typed JSON object. LLM cannot reliably extract created project path, status, or next steps. Wastes tokens on parsing.
No input validation or constraints. Parameters accept arbitrary strings with no format validation for project_name (special chars, length), project_location (path traversal risk), or server_description. Subprocess calls are not sanitized.
Description does not document side effects, prerequisites, or error recovery. Missing: 'This tool creates directories, installs uv, and modifies the filesystem. Requires ~500MB disk space. Partial failures may leave incomplete projects.'
| Scored | Grade | Overall | Spec posture | Rubric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-23 | D | 55 | 2026-07-28+ | v2 |
No error classification or recovery guidance. Errors like 'Failed to install uv' or 'Failed to initialize uv project' give agent no actionable next step. Should suggest: 'Install uv manually from https://astral.sh/uv or retry with elevated permissions.'