This server has only one tool (ping) with a trivial health-check purpose. The tool has a valid description ('Health check tool') and an empty input schema (PingInput with no fields). However, the server is incomplete: it claims to be an 'asana-mcp-server' but implements zero Asana functionality. The ping tool itself is minimal but properly defined. The core issue is that this is a skeleton/stub implementation with no actual domain tools. For a production Asana integration, this would need create_task, list_tasks, update_task, search_tasks, get_project, etc., none of which exist. The single tool present scores reasonably on naming (verb-based) and description (clear), but the overall server is non-functional for its stated purpose.
Health check tool
Server is a stub with only a health-check tool; zero Asana domain functionality implemented. Claims to be 'asana-mcp-server' but has no create_task, list_tasks, update_task, search_tasks, get_project, or any Asana API integration.
ping tool input schema is empty (PingInput with no fields). While valid, it provides no parameters for the LLM to reason about. Health-check tools typically accept optional parameters like 'timeout_ms' or 'include_dependencies' to guide behavior.
Tool description 'Health check tool' is only 18 characters, below the 34-character p10 baseline for production tools. Should explain when to call it, what it checks, and what success/failure means. E.g., 'Verify server health and Asana API connectivity. Returns status ok if all systems operational.'
No error handling or recovery guidance. If ping fails, the LLM has no actionable next step. Should return structured error with retry guidance and diagnostic info.
| Scored | Grade | Overall | Spec posture | Rubric |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-23 | D | 50 | 2026-07-28+ | v2 |
No Asana API credentials or authentication visible in source. Server imports 'asana' package but never uses it. No environment variable injection for API tokens (pattern:secret-injection). If credentials are intended, they must be server-side injected, never exposed as tool parameters.